2020-21
Baseball: Chandler Blackwelder (Soph/INF) - First Team All-American
Baseball: Will Samuelson (Soph/C) - Second Team All-American
Baseball: James Hinson (Soph/INF) - Third Team All-American
Volleyball: Aasia McNeill (Soph/OH) - First Team All-American
2019-20
Women's basketball: Alliyah Chaplin (Soph/G/F) - First Team All-American
Volleyball: Emma Clark (Soph/MH) - First Team All-American
2018-19
Baseball: Logan Bender (Soph/RHP) - First Team All-American
Volleyball: Emma Clark (Fresh/MH) - First Team All-American
2017-18
Baseball: Julian Smith (Soph/P) - Third Team All-American
Women's basketball: Shaniya Lester (Soph/G) - Honorable Mention All-American
2016-17
Baseball:Chandler Jenkins (Soph/OF) - NJCAA DII National Player of the Year; First Team All-American
Volleyball:Megan Fair (Soph/OH) - First Team All-American
Volleyball: Mariah Wallace (Soph/OH) - Second Team All-American
2015-16
Volleyball: Megan Fair (Fresh/OH) - Honorable Mention All-American
Baseball: Ty Andrus (Soph/OF) - Second Team All-American
2014-15
Baseball: Danny Sullivan (Soph/3B) - First Team All-American
2013-14
Baseball: Bryson Bowman (Soph/OF) - Third Team All-American
Women's Basketball: Kadesha Gibbs (Soph/F) - First Team All-American
2012-13
Baseball: Ryan Smith (Fresh/IF) - Third Team All-American
Women's Basketball: Shirley "Anika" Jones (Fresh/G) - First Team All-American
Volleyball: Jennifer Beatty (Soph/OH) - Second Team All-American
2011-12
Baseball: Danny Fraga (Soph/IF) - Second Team All-American
2007-08
Volleyball: Terri Ferber (Soph/MH) - Honorable Mention All-American
2006-07
Men's Basketball: Octreyvius Roebuck (Soph/F) - Honorable Mention All-American
Volleyball: Terri Ferber (Fresh/MH) - Honorable Mention All-American
2005-06
Men's Basketball: Jeremy Yancey (Soph/G) - Second Team All-American
1998-99
Men's Golf: Sumner Alford - Second Team All-American
1994-95
Men's Golf: Travis Bland - Second Team All-American
Men's Golf: Sam Morrow - Third Team All-American
1993-94
Men's Golf: Travis Bland - All-American
1992-93
Men's Golf: Jason Smith - First Team All-American
Men's Golf: Chad Jackson - Second Team All-American
1991-92
Men's Golf: Jason Smith - Third Team All-American
1990-91
Men's Golf: Mark Clodfelter - Second Team All-American
Men's Golf: Brad Turner - Third Team All-American
Men's Golf: Marty White - Honorable Mention All-American
Men's Golf: Bryan Marsh -Honorable Mention All-American
1989-90
Men's Golf: Eddie Martin - First Team All-American
Men's Golf: Bryan Norris - First Team All-American
Men's Golf: Mark Clodfelter - Third Team All-American
Men's Golf: Jim Murray - Third Team All-American
Men's Golf: Brad Turner - Third Team All-American
1984-85
Men's Golf: Jeff Brown - Honorable Mention All-American
1983-84
Men's Golf: Larry Beaver - Second Team All-American